The calm veneer of suburban life in St. Catharines, a city in the Canadian province of Ontario, was shattered on the icy morning of Christmas Eve 1990. A 911 call at 1:18 a.m. to 61 Dundonald Street brought a tumultuous ballet of first responders—firefighters, EMTs, and Constable Weeks of the local police—swarming to the scene. The serenity of the snow-covered houses stood in stark contrast to the chaos within, where a 15-year-old girl, Tammy Lyn Homolka, lay dying in the basement.
Tammy Lyn, blonde and effervescent, with her entire life ahead of her, was choking on her own vomit. "Her skin was very, very gray," the investigative report from June 1996 noted, detailing a scene out of a horror story rather than the Homolka family's suburban home. A distinctive mark etched its way into her otherwise perfect face, a detail Constable Weeks couldn't ignore, even in the chaos of trying to save her life.
While the first responders scrambled to save the young girl, her mother, Dorothy Homolka, descended the stairs, roused from sleep by the blaring sirens and flash of lights. Tammy Lyn's sister, Karla Homolka, and her boyfriend, Paul Bernardo, were in the room, alongside their other sister, Lori. All were silent witnesses to the macabre tableau unfolding before their eyes.
When the police later interviewed the household members, each shared their own version of the evening's events. According to their accounts, Tammy Lyn had dinner around 5 p.m. before engaging in some light drinking: a glass and a half of champagne, two pina coladas, and a few sips from other drinks. Then, she allegedly settled on a separate couch to watch a movie with her sister and her boyfriend.
According to their accounts, they were woken from their slumber by the sound of Tammy Lyn's struggling breaths, choked by her own vomit. In their panic, they moved her to the floor, attempted CPR, and then called the police. Strangely, Bernardo was quick to volunteer that no drugs were involved, a detail nobody had asked about. Karla also mentioned that Tammy Lyn suffered from mild asthma, though she took no medication for it.
The interview was abruptly interrupted by a call confirming Tammy Lyn's death. An eerie hush fell over the room. The aftermath was a tableau of grief: Lori was inconsolable, Karla and Bernardo sat hugging their knees and rocking back and forth in the throes of hysterical crying.
It was here that the narrative took a turn. Five minutes after leaving to console Lori, Constable Weeks returned to find Karla running the washing machine. Inside were the clothes Tammy Lyn had been wearing and the sheet she had been lying on. Why the urgency to wash them when they might be evidence in her sister's sudden death?
As if this weren't perplexing enough, other details didn't add up. The length of time it took to call for help and the delay in moving Tammy Lyn's body seemed strange, as did the fact that a movie started at 11 p.m. was only halfway finished when the emergency began.
The autopsy revealed a bright raspberry-colored burn extending from Tammy Lyn's mouth down to her neck. Karla offered a carousel of explanations, none of them convincing: acne, an allergic reaction to makeup, excessive mouth-to-mouth resuscitation, or a result of being dragged across the carpet by the paramedics. But the photographic evidence told a different story: a vivid, disconcerting burn that couldn't be explained by any of these excuses. Even the coroner was suspicious, hinting at potential sexual activity and drug involvement.
The official cause of death was asphyxia caused by aspiration of vomitus, with the asthma attack as the trigger. Yet the mystery lingered. How could this seemingly healthy, 15-year-old girl with only a slight trace of alcohol in her system suddenly choke to death in the company of her family?
A subsequent review of the case by Chief Provincial Forensic Pathologist, Dr. John Hillsdon-Smith, agreed with the original autopsy’s assertion that the mark on Tammy Lyn's face was a chemical burn. Dr. Hillsdon-Smith hypothesized that the burn was from a strong caustic alkali, possibly splashed onto her face while trying to wipe away vomit.
In the midst of these chilling revelations, a VHS tape surfaced, immortalizing the moments of Tammy Lyn's last night. Yet the officer who found it inexplicably failed to view its contents. It was an oversight that, had it been corrected, could have arrested a chain of events leading to the deaths of two more innocent young women.
As the narrative unfolded, an uneasy truth began to creep into the forefront: Karla Homolka and Paul Bernardo were not innocent bystanders to Tammy Lyn Homolka's death. They were active participants in her demise, guilty of unspeakable crimes. As the investigation continued, the insidious nature of their relationship, their depravity, and their horrendous acts of violence against innocent young women became chillingly apparent.
The video transcript (Extremely Disturbing)
This is the video transcript which was found in Invisible Darkness: The Strange Case of Karla Homolka and Paul Bernardo
Paul pulled down her green track pants and Karla pushed her shirt up. Paul started videotaping his fingers lubricating her vagina and then put his penis in her. The camera was zoomed in on his penis going in and out of Tammy's vagina. Karla told him to hurry up and Paul told her to shut up. Tammy's right hand was casually relaxed across her belly.
"Quiet," she said. Karla had been holding the halothane-soaked
cloth over her sister's mouth and nose. Periodically she
poured more halothane on the cloth and checked Tamniy's
breathing.
"Will you blow me?" Paul asked, just as a joke.
"Yes."
"Suck on her breasts," he said. The multicolored sweater Tammy
was wearing had been pulled right up around her neck. Karla started
to mouth her breasts. "Now, suck,"
Paul had pulled his penis out and changed shots. Karla was
kneeUng between her sister's legs. Paul pushed on her head and
Karla started to perform cunnilingus on her sister.
"Put your tongue out," he ordered. "Probe. You're not doing it."
Tammy had her period, and Karla was very unhappy.
"I am so," Karla whimpered.
"Do it. Lick her cunt. Lick it up . . . Lick it clean. Lick it clean . . ."he
instructed her.
"I am . . ." Karla replied.
"Put your fingers inside . . ."he cajoled.
Karla said no. He told her to do it again. Karla was becoming
increasingly unhappy and distraught.
"Do it now, quick, quick, quick. Right now. Right inside ..."Karla started to do it, pushing her right index finger in and out of
her sister.
"Three fingers. Right inside." Then he told her to do exactly the
thing she most deplored. "Taste it." Karla refused.
"Taste it. Put it in. Taste it. Put it inside and taste it."
"I did."
"Taste it. Inside. Inside. Inside and taste it. Quick."
"No," she whined, and continued to finger Tammy.
"Inside. Deep. Deep."
"1 did," Karla said. Paul repeated himself. "I did," Karla said again.
Karla reluctantly licked her now bloodstained fingers.
"Taste good? Not bad, eh?" he inquired.
She said no. He asked again. "Taste good?"
Karla looked right into the camera, "Fucking disgusting ..."
Ignoring her, he asked again, "Does it taste good?" Paul knew what
was wrong and thought it was funny.
Karla had been holding the halothane-soaked cloth over her sister's
face. Now she went back up to check her breathing and Paul
inserted his penis in Tammy's anus.
"Up her cunt, up her ass. How's that?" he said happily.
In 1993, just three years after Tammy Lyn's death, Bernardo was arrested in connection with a series of sexual assaults and murders, earning him the grim moniker of "Scarborough Rapist". During the course of his trial, Bernardo's lawyer came across the tapes that had been overlooked during the initial investigation into Tammy Lyn's death.
Those tapes documented an unspeakable horror. Karla Homolka and Paul Bernardo, drugged Tammy Lyn, sexually assaulted her, and recorded the entire ordeal. The 'halothane', a potent anesthetic stolen by Karla from the veterinary clinic where she worked, had been used to drug Tammy Lyn and was the likely cause of the burn on her face. Their horrific act was what led to Tammy Lyn choking on her own vomit and ultimately dying.
Karla was subsequently arrested and a deal with the prosecution was struck, which would come to be known infamously as the "Deal with the Devil". In exchange for her testimony against Bernardo, she received a reduced sentence of twelve years for manslaughter. The deal was highly controversial, especially when the tapes emerged, proving that Karla was a far more active participant in the crimes than she admitted.
Paul Bernardo was found guilty of first-degree murder, kidnapping, forcible confinement and aggravated sexual assault in both the cases of Leslie Mahaffy and Kristen French, other young victims of the couple, and was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for at least 25 years.
However, despite the confirmation of their crimes and subsequent punishments, the death of Tammy Lyn Homolka remained shrouded in a pall of mystery, horror, and an uneasy sense of justice not entirely served. It was a chilling reminder of the depths of human depravity that could lurk behind the facade of an ordinary suburban home.
Discussion